7 Comments
-
Ross Urquhart
Dr. Sosteric,
Amazing to read your expose of academic writing. It’s true, of course, but for a practicing academic to put it down officially and in some detail is unexpected. I’ve heard friends of mine in academia complain that it takes thirty years for concepts turned up in research projects to be absorbed into the “outside” world, yet, they never twigged on to the notion they may be squeezing the bottleneck. Good on you – we need more of this. Ross Urquhart -
Robert Ostrow
It is true Dr. Sosteric, that revealing intentions in a given research paper is extremely hard. I am at this point in my life undergoing this transition of what my research is all about. It is extremely difficult, but in the end, will be very rewarding. I have learned alot in the last number of months. I still use concepts, words, phrases that no one on the planet would understand. I would say that revealing your true intent in your research project, helps people understand what you are trying to contribute. It is stressful, hard, but it is extremely worth it. Robert
-
Dr.Sosteric, Congratulations for a brave comments about the sad state of academic ventures. It is true that the academia maintained a distinct identity which is cut off from the common world. This is turning upside down after the arrival of ICT. I dont know how far it will go. Hopefully the reversal shouldnt be for worse.
-
The main thing I’m seeing right now is the movement of mass media into the internet in a big way. I think this is being facilitated by Google, which doesn’t seem to have any problem with manipulating the flow of search results, while not telling anybody how they do it. This coupled with some remarkably regressive new age spirituality (“law of attraction”) doesn’t bode well for any significant change. It really comes down to the academics and their willingness to penetrate the collective consciousness. That won’t happen for a while because before it does us academics got some things to learn about writing, educashion, how to get people’s attention, and hold it, and so on.
-
adeleine
Dr. Sosteric,
Thank you for pointing out something so obvious and giving me a reason to write the way I would like to write, rather than feeling as if I am not as good as others because of my difficulty in reiterating some academic material. Although I have been blessed to have some amazing professors here at Athabasca, who in their own right have a very practical way of teaching and making the courses “student friendly”, what you write about in this article gives me direction. I know that I still have to write papers according to academic standards in order to pass my courses; however, keeping my “intent” in mind will afford me the opportunity to complete my degree with a purpose.
-
Alistair Lee
“The more obscure, complicated, and convoluted your writing, the better, smarter, more worthy of consideration you must be.”
That’s certainly the case with Michel Foucault, haha
-
Shilpashri Karbhari
Hi Dr Sosteric:
I agree with you one hundred percent. As I come close to completion of one year at my institution as an Assistant Professor,I felt relieved when I read your post/message. I needed this mentoring. The underlying message of your post challenges me to think seriously about my research interests and how to get his information across to my audience in an easy to digest manner. Yet remain solidly grounded in sociology and strive for change. I feel energized about my writing or my recent dissertation and envision writing for Socjourn. Often times we are made to feel left out when we are unable to publish or take our research further.
Sincerely,
Shilpashri Karbhari
